What's in This Guide?
- 1 Our Recommendation
- 2 Also great
- 3 Budget Choice
- 4 Also Read
- 5 Our Recommendation
- 6 Its Recommendation
- 7 Reasons to Trust Us
- 8 Our Selection Procedure of The Best Crib Mattresses
- 9 What’s in A Mattress?
- 10 Why These Certifications Are Relevant?
- 11 Does Off-Gassing Matter and What About `breathability`?
- 12 Our Testing Process
- 13 Our Recommendation
- 14 Not a Deal Breaker, but Flaws Nonetheless.
- 15 Great as Well
- 16 Budget Choice
- 17 Competitiveness
- 18 How to Care For, Use, and Maintain
Last Updated on January 26, 2023 by Sandra Allens
Top Pick: Little Dreamer, Moonlight Slumber
If you’re looking for the best Crib Mattress, but don’t want to waste your time researching about these, then just go for this one.
After a long research, we recommend Little Dreamer, Moonlight Slumber as our first choice.
One only to do Shopping for the best crib mattresses only once in your lifetime if you are planning on getting a baby. We found that the Little Dreamer slumbers in the moonlight was the best crib mattress for the most families after testing it for a month and researching it for 11 hours over hundreds of crib mattresses. Besides offering a classic, comfortable, and affordable design, the best big kid beds provide you with a firm, cleanable surface that is easy to maintain.
Little Dreamer, Moonlight Slumber
A Good Crib Mattress
Little Dreamer slumbers in the moonlight were the most comfortable, firm, and easy-to-clean mattresses we examined.
Moonlight Slumber’s Little Dreamer Crib Mattress for parents performs well in all of the categories that are most important to them. The idea of buying a mattress with twin sides is a smart one since a baby side is firm and a toddler side is softer. Whenever messes occur in performance-knit fabrics, parents can clean them easily by dampening sponges, water, or detergent. The sheet is square-cornered, has square edges, and has an appropriate weight for changing sheets. A fire-resistant fabric is wrapped around the foam core, and a layer of medical-grade padding is added on top of that. This mattress is a Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US-certified product due to its low VOC content. The mattresses are made in the USA and come with a lifetime warranty. They typically last about 8years. This brand offers customer service as well.
Lightweight Natural Cotton from Naturepedic
In Case You Prefer Organic
Despite being less expensive and comfortable, Naturepedic’s mattress is a good option at an affordable price for a fire retardant-free, certified organic mattress.
In our view, the Naturepedic Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic is the best option from the range of “organic” crib mattresses that are available to parents who are specific about buying a crib mattress that complies with the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS). We found the Naturepedic mattress to be the most comfortable and most affordable organic mattress we tested. Our mattress evaluation found a few mattresses costing more than $400.
It is made by brushing organic cotton fabric with a food-grade, waterproof plastic coating, then wrapping it in polyethylene and adding organic cotton batting. Fire retardants are not present in this product, nor does it contain traditional fire retardants. Greenguard Gold certification has also been granted to the product. Aside from its light weight and waterproof properties, it is more readily available online and in top baby stores, and it has a lifetime warranty. It is significantly lighter than organic mattresses that use innerspring coils.
Soy-Based Foam Core for Sealy Crib Mattresses
About $100 for The Best
A simple monochromatic design suggests a mattress that is less expensive, easier to clean, and more durable than the Sealy mattress.
Due to its low price point, our top pick makes an excellent choice for parents who prefer one that’s lightweight, durable, and easy to care for. Greenguard Gold-certified so they fail to emit harmful substances, Sealy mattresses are also CertiPUR-US certified so they emit low volatile organic compounds. The reason is that this book lacks a double-sided design, making it more suitable for younger children than older ones. A little over eight pounds, it was surprisingly light. This simplifies the process of changing sheets. Even with the waterproof laminated cover, you may not get the greatest amount of use from this item. Since its quality is low and the design isn’t two-sided, it may not be as durable. One-year warranty and good customer service are also included.
The Moonlight Slumber of A Little Dreamer
Choosing the Right Crib Mattress
In our crib mattress testing, we found the Little Dreamer slumbers in the moonlight to be the most comfortable, firm, and easily cleaned crib mattress.
Lightweight Natural Cotton from Naturepedic
The Organic Way Is Best
Despite being less expensive and comfortable, Naturepedic’s mattress is a good option at an affordable price for a fire retardant-free, certified organic mattress.
Soy-Based Foam Core for Sealy Crib Mattresses
About $100 for The Best
As a short-term pick, we selected the Sealy mattress we chose because it is a good firmness, comfortable, and easy to care for mattress, but since it is one-sided, it will not last long as our top pick.
Parents know that their children need to sleep. During your toddler or infant years, you are likely to require more than ten hours of sleep every night, along with a few naps during the day. In the first two weeks of life, newborns sleep 16-17 hours a day. Approximately 9k hours of sleep are required by the time a child turns two.
During this period, children most often sleep in their cribs. For the majority of kids, they sleep in their cribs until they are old enough to move to twin/full-sized bed. In many families, toddler beds are converted around their second birthday. Infants of any size and all ages are commonly accommodated on mattresses that parents purchase.
Reasons to Trust Us
I wish to acknowledge Brandon Boor, PhD as the author for this article on indoor air quality, who is an expert in the area. In addition to being a professor Purdue University, he has also been actively involved in student activities. Researchers from Duke University have published the results of findings that best crib mattresses contain hazardous (VOCs) that can harm human health if inhaled. In response to my questions about environmental concerns, I spoke with Tasha Stoiber of the Environmental Working Group and Bobbi Wilding of Clean and Healthy New York.
With over twenty years of experience in the mattress industry, Chicago mattress expert Mike Cohen has over two decades of running his own company; and sprouts San Francisco owner Suzanne Price possesses MBA from Columbia Business School and the vice chair of Children’s Environmental Health Center (CEHC). Among the topics they discussed were how the crib mattresses are exchanged and what questions parents ask when shopping for a crib mattress. I found information on crib mattress recalls on Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) website.
The opportunity to speak with a dozen parents from across the country who shared with me their opinions and experiences about crib mattresses and also what they liked and disliked about them has been a great pleasure for me. As part of my review process, I read an excellent number of reviews as well as conducted a great deal of online research. This was an integral part of my evaluation process.
As of now, I have been contributing columnists to a number in national publications that deal with health, parenting, and medicine. My son is seven years old and my daughter is four years old. In fact, they just recently graduated (after having spent years in cribs) from the toddler beds to big-kid mattresses. My child is 7 plus years old and I have changed crib sheets for her, cleaned up crib mess, and put her in the crib for the past seven years. Having a good night’s sleep is very important to me, and I think my kids also agree with that, so I do understand that there are some things parents should know before making a purchase.
Our Selection Procedure of The Best Crib Mattresses
When you search “crib mattress” on Amazon, you will find over 600 results. We researched and interviewed experts, reviewed parent feedback, and reviewed a variety of best of lists before making a list of the best crib mattresses currently available. After additional research on the internet and discussions with manufacturers, we developed a list of mattresses that we tested at home. After analyzing 12 mattresses, the list was narrowed down to 12.
The materials used in each crib mattress and the differences between each brand were factors I used to narrow my choices among crib mattress brands. Our conversations included those with Barry Cik of Naturepedic, Michael Rothbard of Newton Baby, as well as representatives from Colgate, Kolcraft, and Moonlight Slumber.
We had to test every mattress that was legal size, so it had to be at least 2714 by 5158, and it hadn’t been thicker than six inches. If you choose this size, it will fit snug in the crib. Fitted sheets should be used appropriately in order to maintain a safe crib mattress’ shape. Furthermore, the fitted sheet should completely cover the crib, up to a couple of fingers from the edges.
Based on a policy statement published in 2016 by the American Academy of Pediatrics, one recommendation is ensuring an infant’s sleep surface remains firm and does not indent or conform to his or her head. As with any mattress, using a memory foam mattress can pose some risks to an infant because it may trap them inside a pocket or indent, leading to suffocation. The guide does not include the AAP’s viewpoint on memory foam, in order to align with its position.
A Great Crib Mattress Should Be Able to Satisfy the Following Criteria, as Determined by Our Research, Expert Interviews, and other Personal Experience, Such As:
- An even surface. In addition to comfort, a crib mattress must be able to provide a reliably reliable surface. Online reviewers often noted that mattresses were thin, or likely to bed during sheet exchanges, so we did not test mattresses made with memory foam.
- Easily cleanable cover. Our testers tested mattresses had leak-proof covers, mattresses with cotton covers, as well as mattresses with removable, washable covers. In terms of ease of cleaning, we considered accidents and also spills to be common in the cribs.
- An ultralight design. When the mattress is heavy and awkward, it makes changing the sheets more difficult. There was no difference in weight between the mattresses that we tested.
- Durability. When a child moves to a full-size or twin bed, the majority of parents will keep the crib mattress in at least 2 years. The best crib mattress may be used for much longer than by families with multiple children. In addition to considering the fill’s durability and its ability to retain the shape, we also took into account the cover’s durability and its ability to stay strong without rippling.
- Noise-free cover. It is easier for a child to make more noise if the mattress cover is crunchier. We selected a mattress cover that was both supple and noiseless.
- Comfort. Some firms mattresses are more luxurious than others, although most infants need a firm mattress for sleeping. Parents can change their toddler’s mattress around the 10 month mark, as 2 sided mattresses and one firm and one softer side have proven more comfortable for toddlers.
- It doesn’t bounce. In order to avoid bouncing their children while they sleep, many parents worry about crib mattress reliability. Over a four-week period, my kids tested this feature extensively.
- A reasonable price. The best crib mattresses we tested cost between 50 and 300 dollars. Reviews claimed that mattresses sag after months, and the covers rip easily, especially on the cheaper models which start around $35. Though the average mattress costs over $300, and especially organic mattresses are more expensive than that, we decided it isn’t worth it to spend more. Some experts said purchasing a $400 crib mattress is a bad idea. Rather than worrying about quality/safety, parents want their children to feel at ease with that price.
- Excellent customer service and a solid warranty. An important aspect of a brand’s warranty and customer service is the ability to get in touch in case something goes wrong, such as a mattress that sags after less use or is torn. The number of people that could be reached the company was noted, along with the fact that there was no number listed. Several online reviews mention issues with customer service; we took these into consideration as well.
- Materials outside of certification. A Greenguard Gold certified mattress emits a minimal level of volatile organic compounds. Further to foam mattresses already certified by CertiPUR-US, we also reviewed mattresses free of all forms of formaldehyde, lead, ozone-depleting chemicals, and flame retardants. Further, the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) was tested on organic mattresses. The certifications all came from where? The materials used in crib mattresses are discussed.
What’s in A Mattress?
Despite not being specifically part of above criteria, we checked the materials in mattress during testing, in addition to meeting certification standards.
We began by examining the filling in the core. The innersprings of a crib mattress are typically either foam-cored or enclosed in polyester cotton, or other fabrics. Special crib mattresses generally consist of polyethylene, cotton batting, and coconut husk. The mattresses we tested came with information about their contents.
Mattresses made of foam are typically lightweight, weighing between 5 and 13 pounds. Petroleum-based polyurethane is most commonly used in foam mattresses. Many mattresses claim to be formaldehyde-free. Formaldehyde is present (usually as an adhesive) in some polyurethane foam types. Generally, green mattresses contain some soy oil, which replaces the petroleum oil used to make polyurethane foam (typically 20 to 25 percent). In addition to latex and bamboo fiber foam mattresses, you can also find them.
There is a slight weight difference between innerspring mattresses and those without. In order to choose a mattress, you have to take into account the coil count and steel thickness. For mattresses of varying firmness, the coil count and gauge of steel of the coils (i.e., the smaller the number) increase. Babies don’t really need a lot of support when it comes to crib mattresses (the average is around 80 pounds), so 135 to 150 coils should be fine (between 12 and 20 pounds). Innerspring mattresses typically have boundary rods lining the outer edges so that they are firm and do not sag at the edges.
Added to this, spring-to-mattress mattresses may also contain layers of cushioning or padding, either composed of polyurethane foam, cotton fabric, or coco fibers, with an insulation layer composed of either woven polyester or cotton. It will be more difficult for the manufacturers to create better mattresses because there will be more layers and the materials used for the layers and pads will be more durable.
It is fairly common for mattress manufacturers to use organic materials such as latex or coconut fiber in making mattresses that are used for special occasions. To test the effectiveness of the Newton Baby sandwich bag, a commonly used sandwich bag, we used a food safe plastic sandwich bag for the testing. Another certified organic mattress combined with “wavesupport technology”, this mattress uses polyethylene wave technology to give the mattress its unique characteristics.
My next step was to examine the mattress’s ticking. Cotton, food plastic, and waterproof vinyl are possible covers for crib mattresses, depending on their type. The thicker the vinyl cover, the more it tends to tear, rip, and dry easier. PVC, a plasticizer containing phthalates, has been found to disrupt an animal’s hormonal balance. Vinyl is softened and flexible because of the phthalates it contains. Many mattresses feature phthalate-free and PVC-free labels, since certain types of phthalates are subject to stringent regulations.
The mattresses were examined for their construction, as well as their materials. Some mattresses have seams around cover, and others are seamless. In certain mattresses, the seams appeared much stronger or tighter than in others. It’s usually durable for three or four years if the mattress has no seams, a tight zipper, and tightly made seams-and one can see them when you’re in the front of it.
Experts agree that a mattress’s materials are better the more expensive it is. We consulted experts to determine what makes a mattress more expensive. As a guarantee that this would be the case, we have sorted our test group from the cheapest to the most expensive. There were some very cheap mattresses we offered, but that are either filled with coils, do not have boundary wires, have one layer of vinyl covering, or are made up of polyester without a vinyl cover. In a lot of innerspring mattresses, the border wires were made of polyurethane foam and the foam was overlaid with polyester border wires while other mattresses had wires encased in plastic. There are generally two sides to mattresses sold at a higher price point: one side is softer for toddlers and one side firmer for babies. In addition to the organic cotton, the socks were also brushed with food-grade polyethylene to make them look like natural cotton, and the knitted fabric was water- and odor-resistant.
Why These Certifications Are Relevant?
We opted to examine mattresses that were examined by an independent group since scientists are unable to know what effect VOCs might have on children’s health. We tested foam mattresses that are low VOC and Greenguard Gold , as well as those that CertiPUR-US certified. It’s GOTS- and Greenguard Gold-certified and does not contain polyurethane foam. It is free from vinyl, plastic, and phthalates too.
Why Those Certifications Matter:
- Greenguard Gold certifications are typically for products used by people over the age of 60 or in families with children. (Also known as Children and Schools certification). It verifies that an item complies with tense VOC limits to be used indoors. A third-party NGO will provide unbiased empirical data.
- CertiPUR-US certified tests for content, emissions of volatile organic compounds, and durability in foam mattresses.
- In order to meet your needs, you should seek out GOTS certification. This means that the mattress is free of all forms of chemicals, polyurethane foam, flame retardants, formaldehyde, pesticides, glues, or other non-organic ingredients.
Cohen said certification is a plus because it assures parents that the product they are buying is working. Customers can trust foam mattresses that are CertiPUR-US certified. Despite the fact that these certifications may offer parents more information about gassing off, you should be aware some mattresses still come with PVC vinyl covers despite being Greenguard Gold certified.
No matter what materials are used in the production of crib mattresses in the U.S., compliance with CPSC part 1632 and 1633 regulations is crucial. There may be cotton or wool of a mattress that has had boric acid naturally applied or there may be foam that has been treated with flame retardant. Wool, latex, and baking soda are examples of substrates that can meet this standard.
Does Off-Gassing Matter and What About `breathability`?
As the AAP’s guidelines for safe sleep, there are no link between SIDS and the release of “toxic gases” from sleeping mattresses. Researchers in the UK examined the toxic-gas confusion in the 1990s.
The Purdue University environmental engineering professor Brandon Boor,, published several articles on the effects of VOCs on crib mattresses. He answered a few questions about crib mattresses and VOCs. Researchers analyzed the release and effect of VOCs on infants while they slept from 20 used and 20 new polyurethane foam crib mattresses and beds.
Variety of chemicals have been found to be contaminated in crib mattresses. The chemicals that comprise these categories include (VOCs), and semivolatile organic compounds. Flammables and plasticizers are among the compounds in crib mattresses, as both foam fill as well waterproof covers contain them. More than 30 of these compounds are released into the air.
It doesn’t tell you anything definitive about what’s inside a box if it carries labeling such as “natural,” “pure,” or “eco.” New mattresses emit four times as many volatile organic compounds as older mattresses, according to a study by Boor in 2014. Psychologist David Stapleton, PhD, at Duke University analyzing fire retardants. The study is not expected to reveal the names of any specific products or manufacturers, noted Boor.
However, Boor contends that consumers still aren’t helped by knowing crib mattresses emit VOCs in order to make informed purchases. Mattresses had been independently certified by CertiPur-US and Greenguard Gold as low VOC emitters were tested. Where is the healthy body temperature for infants at rest? In fact, Boor said there hasn’t been any correlation established between the research and toxicology as well health outcomes.
It is true some parents prefer to put their babies sleep on organic mattresses, but we have not found any evidence to indicate that organic mattresses are necessarily healthier than conventional ones, so we didn’t think about organic mattresses as superior to conventional mattresses. There are two types of certifications: GOTS and Ankylos, which is a certification that ensures that a product is naturally natural, pure, certified organic, and eco-friendly, and not just a generic claim.
While VOCs are primarily concentrated in the crib mattress, That they are found in many other places in the nursery as well. Toys made of plastic and laminate floorings, as well as cribs and also dresser drawers that are made of pressed wood, are the main emitters. According to Boor, you should try a holistic, but expensive approach to get rid of chemical sources in your home.
Here’s the deal with crib mattresses. The AAP study does not support the claim crib mattresses with “breathability” reduce the risk of an infant breathing carbon dioxide back into his or her lungs during sleep, or that they prevent SIDS. Neither an AAP representor nor the chairperson of the AAP Task Force on SIDS recall any research pertaining to this issue from 2000. Our attention was diverted by the claims about breathability made by crib mattress makers.
Our Testing Process
My three children and I tested twelve crib mattresses delivered to homes over the period of the month.
The mattress covers and inside covers were in boxes, so I removed them from the packaging and noted all the labels on them, including what materials had been used to make the covers. Fitting each mattress to the crib’s sides and edges, I fabricated it to be snug without extra space around edges or sides.
I timed myself every time I changed sheets in order to determine if any sheets took more time to change than the average. Carter’s sheets and thicker mattresses.
A six pound weight was placed in the middle of mattress to measure its firmness. This weight is estimated to be a little bit heavier than an average newborn. The less expensive model of mattresses I tested exhibited significant sagging even at this weight. Additionally, I sat on each mattress and took notes on how they felt as I touched the outside edges and corners.
My kids were growing up and as they grew older I allowed them the freedom to play, to jump, to roll, and to sleep on every mattress in the house. Mattresses made from foam tend to be more solid than their spring equivalents, although those made of springs tend to bounce more. I was immediately interested in finding out more information about Moonlight Slumber mattresses when I heard my children discuss them.
Water and juice were also spilled excessively during the spill tests. Whenever I spilled a quarter bowl of liquid in a mattress, my kids or I would wait a few minutes and then drain it. A waterproof mattress is easier to clean than a cotton mattress, which is obviously not able to keep liquids out. Additionally, we used applesauce to dry up a lot more messes. It is usually easy to find no seam mattresses. Since cotton covers I would need to clean would obscure the seams, I didn’t test them initially.
I then tried pulling on the seams and also edges of each mattress cover, dragging my keys along surface as much as possible, to see if it would puncture easily. When I was tugging on or applying pressure to the seams of the mattresses, I could easily rip them. All of these mattresses are made with three-layer vinyl covers from more strong materials which easily withstand testing.
To come to the end of my mattress search, I decided to focus on price, material, and warranty to determine which mattresses stood out to me.
Little Dreamer, Moonlight Slumber
pick offers hardy construction, comfort, ease of cleaning, and the best price/quality of all best crib mattresses that we tested. We found that Little Dreamer, Moonlight Slumber was the most versatile, easy-to-use, easy-to-clean, and affordable crib mattress we reviewed. This mattress was the best from every perspective when deciding on which mattress to get. Our experience was that the softer side was ideal for toddlers, as well as surprisingly comfortable for newborns.
In our research, we found that Moonlight Slumber has the best cleaning features of any mattress we tested. If necessary, parents can quickly and easily clean up small and large spills with its unique knit cover, which is highly water-, odor-, and stain-resistant. With the unique design of this mattress, you won’t find many seams exposed that will point towards it being an ideal place for small messes to hide, so even the messiest of messes won’t end up as tiny crevices to hide in.
LunaLight Slumber is generally in the middle of the pack when it comes to weight. This mattress has square corners and edges, so it is easier to change the sheets on it, which is not the case with most other mattresses. I noticed that the cover was very supple and made little noise as my children rolled and rolled while sleeping.
Greenguard Gold certification verifies that foam mattress has low VOCs. To prevent this, the polyurethane foam fill of the mattress is surrounded with a flame-resistant gauze-like material, rather than chemicals (all of which exist on other mattresses).
Foam fill meant that there was not much bounce (despite my kids’ attempts). According to our research, the material of the mattress and the user reviews suggest that it should last for decades. One mother has used Little Dreamer, Moonlight Slumber for seven years and still loves it to this day. Moonlight Slumber backs the mattress with a limited eight-year warranty.
The ability to change sheets faster and easier is made possible by square corners. There are 11 best crib mattresses Moonlight Slumber makes, including the classic Little Dreamer, which is highly Known. The company offers not only toddler mattresses but also twin and also full-size versions of Little Dreamer as well.
Not a Deal Breaker, but Flaws Nonetheless.
Our biggest complaint about this mattress was its price. The Little Dreamer, Moonlight Slumber usually sells for just under $200 on Amazon, although this could be considered too expensive for parents who are shopping for a crib and other major items as well. The budget pick is a great option if you have a limited budget but want a great option.
When choosing a mattress, you should take into account how you want to use it. When you have a child for quite a long time, and/or when you adopt another child, you’ll probably want a mattress will last. The mattress like this one provides value. Choose a less expensive mattress if your child won’t be sleeping there often, or if there isn’t air conditioning.
A December 2017 settlement was reached between Lunalight Sleep and the (FTC). Moonlight Sleep claimed that some crib mattresses were carbon dioxide free and endorsed certifications they didn’t disclose. Our experience assembling this guide informed us that much of the marketing terminology used in this category is meaningless. We also learned about the case while researching this guide that is not directly related to the top-choice mattress that we selected.
Great as Well
Lightweight Natural Cotton from Naturepedic
If You Prefer Organic,
Despite being less expensive and also comfortable, Naturepedic’s mattress is a good option at an affordable price for a fire retardant-free, certified organic mattress.
Naturepedic Cotton Classic Lightweight Classic is the perfect crib mattress for a mother who is looking for a lightweight, easy when clean, and bouncy option. In addition to offering the most value for the money, the Classic was also the most comfortable mattress we reviewed. In comparison, most of its competitors sell mattresses for more than $400; this one is around $300. (Naturepedic also offers a two-sided version, which is slightly more expensive.)
A Naturepedic mattress also includes polyethylene core, two layers of organic cotton fabric, two layers of organic cotton batting, and a waterproof PVC coating. Using polyethylene plastic, the company molds a wave-like form and fills it with organic cotton, a concept it calls “wavesupport technology.”. No traditional fire extinguisherS or gaskets are used in Naturepedic mattresses to meet the government’s flammability standards. Mattresses that we tested were not found to contain concentrated fire retardants that are harmful to infants.
Cleanliness is facilitated by the minimal seams on the Naturepedic. As least expensive mattress in Naturepedic’s lightweight line, even though it is about $60 or more costly than our top pick, it is least expensive overall. Comparatively, it is considerably lighter, weighing 12 pounds as opposed to competitors using innersprings.
Due to its waterproof coating and seam-free sides, the Naturepedic makes cleanup easier. There aren’t crevices to trap dirt or water, so diaper puddles don’t accumulate. Rolling around on NaturePedic mattress didn’t make no noise, and because of the foam filling, it didn’t bounce.
An organization dedicated to promoting environmental health in New York’s capital, Clean and Healthy New York, recommended Naturepedic mattresses. Her daughter’s twin-size Naturepedic mattress is very important to Wilding because it adheres to the preferred standards for transparency. “I know what my responsibilities are,” she replied.
Baby Foam Mattress Sealy Soybean
It Costs About $100 to Get the Best
In terms of stability, weight and ease of cleaning, it is like our pick, but it has one sided construction, so it won’t last long.
For a price around half that of the top choice, the Sealy Soy Foam Core Mattress offers best balance in terms of safety, durability, comfort, and easy to clean. Similarly to our top pick, the Little Dreamer, Moonlight Slumber, Sealy mattress filled by polyurethane foam and has been Greenguard certified for reduced volatile organic compounds. It does not have a 2-sided design, so it may not be as durable like our pick and less comfortable for older kids.
The Sealy mattress we tested had a 2 sided design that made it more comfortable than Moonlight Slumber and its firm angle was similar Moonlight Slumber. Our slightly more expensive organic pick was also more comfortable.
It is incredibly easy to change sheets on Sealy mattress that we chose because it weighs just over eight pounds, the lightest among the three mattresses. Covers made of vinyl can be easily cleaned, but they tend to be less durable than other materials. Having pronounced seams makes this pick more difficult to clean, and tugging on those seams causes them to tumble apart right away, indicating that it is not well-made as the other two. This appliance has a warranty of only six months, which is far below the standards of our top picks. In comparison to the Moonlight Slumber and Naturepedic picks, this mattress has a firm feel, a plastic cover, loose seams, and a short warranty.
Based on our testing, we divided our 12 crib mattresses into 2 categories: best of petroleum oilcrib mattresses made with organic cotton or food plastic, and more affordable crib mattresses made with synthetic materials.
While they were very comfortable, six of our top-rated mattresses made with premium materials were difficult during cleaning, so they didn’t make our top selection. It is first mattress belonging to this category to be created by Newton Baby. The interior of this mattress contains woven polymers, air, and food-grade polymers. It costs $300. This product is 100 percent recyclable and contains ten percent woven polymer that is foodsafe. Japan’s customers love Newton Baby’s firm mattress covers because of the materials, according to the company’s CEO, Michael Rothbard. The material looks perfect for babies, and I was brainstorming ways to improve crib mattresses.
There is a removable fabric covering that can be machine washed. It is soft, luxurious, and water-resistant, but does not guarantee total waterproofness. In the case of spills, such as a sippy cup spilled or child wetting himself after he had outgrown diapers, it doesn’t repel, but instead flows right in. If you want to let your child lie on our picks again, you’ll have to take the cover off, wash and air-dry it before you can use it again. If there’s been a major incident or spill over the mattress, like every parent knows when their child gets stomach bug, usually involves washing the cover also the mattress in the bath/shower, cleaning it with mild detergent, as well then letting it air-dry.
In addition to the Sealy soybean foam mattress, the Colgate Classica III (Eco) also boasted a soft filling made from polyurethane foam with plant-based additives. With a waterproof backing and organic cotton top, but a dual-sided design that’s turn off, it is made from organic cotton. Unless the mattress’ backing is waterproof, I can’t really wash top layer because water soaks right into it. Whether the mattress’ backing is waterproof or not doesn’t matter much when it comes to cleaning top layer. Product lifetime guarantees are a very good thing to know. The additional mattress cover would have been more cost-effective than adding it to my $180 package.
One of the other Colgate mattresses came on the short-list as a best crib mattress, but it was the heaviest at twenty pounds, meaning it was difficult to change linens. The 3-ply vinyl top on the Sealy soy foam-core mattress is similar to what you’ll find on the other mattresses, and at a lower price.
This mattress is made up of fabric wrapped innerspring coils and border wires, as well as polyurethane foam and also other fillings, including cotton felt and blended fibre batting. I liked the vinyl cover on this mattress and how easily I could clean it. The sheets didn’t seem to be as heavy as fifteen pounds when it was time for change them. Since I can’t tell the difference between the toddler side and infant side, I prefer Sealy soy foam mattresses for their feel and price.
Another Sealy Comfort Rest mattress was tested with springs and thinner vinyl top. It is easy to break the cover. I also pull the seams out easily, the mattress makes a lot of noise when the children roll around it, and overall it is an inferior mattress to the Sealy soy mattress.
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress was eagerly anticipated, even though it was very expensive. I found it on Amazon with 4 stars in Safety first Heavenly Dreams 5, 3,000 reviews and many positive testimonials, but was not particularly impressed with it and contemplated returning it because its thin cover and polyester fiber filling suggested that it would not last for really long. Choosing our budget pick is a better option if you are in need of secondary mattress to the grandma’s place.
There are 150 coils in Kolcraft Sleep Therapeutic, though there isn`t border wire for edge support. Wires inside would make it less comfortable for a larger child to press on it if lasted long. This mattress sank more than others when placed a 6-pound weight on. Even though I felt the vinyl was durable, I can pull some seams with good tug.
How to Care For, Use, and Maintain
Your Baby’s Safety and The Longevity of Your Crib Mattress Can Be Ensured by Following the Following Crib Mattress Care Tips.
- Air out a brand new mattress. After you unpack it for your baby and it begins to sleep on it, let it rest for several days.
- Let the baby sleep on the backs. Keep everything else out of the crib. The AAP and also CPSC have detailed information about blankets, pillows, and stuffed animals that should never be used in a crib. To reduce risk of the entrapment, suffocation, and also strangulation, the AAP recommends that consumers do not write their baby down on the adult-sized bed, armchair or couch.
- Test your mattress with two fingers. As soon as crib mattress is placed inside, the fitted sheet should be placed on top of it. You should not have more than 2 fingers between the crib’s sides and also the mattress.
- Time your flip correctly. Until your child is mobile and come up neck control, a two-side mattress can be used. Make sure you consult the pediatrician before changing the mattress if you’re not sure.
- Protect the mattress by using a fitted sheet. A waterproof mattress pad can also prevent messes from making their way past ticking of a crib mattress that lacks a waterproof cover.
- Follow the instructions. To wipe down the mattress after a spill, simply use a damp sponge. Using mild dish soap will suffice for larger spills. A clean, dry mattress should be covered with a fresh sheet to prevent mold and bacteria. You should read the instructions which come with the mattress before one uses it, since mattresses that are not waterproof or covered in cotton will have different instructions.
- Beware of indenting. It’s important for infants and newborns that mattresses remain firm after repeated usage. An infant placed face-down or rolled to the side of a mattress with a pocket or indentation is at higher risk of suffocation and rebreathing if a mattress has that feature.
- Ensure proper storage. To prevent bacteria and mildew from festering, best crib mattresses need to be cleaned and stored properly.